Week 2: Response from
Rabbi Brian Glusman
It is important to note that in this law, Maimonides refers to action, not motivations or feelings. Maimonides asks, "What is complete teshuvah? When you confront the same situation in which you sinned in the past... yet (this time) you abstain from committing the sin." I believe that this concept is a key factor in understanding the Jewish attitude towards "sin." According to Judaism, thinking or fantasizing about doing something inappropriate is not viewed as a serious offense. Judaism is very practical and understanding of human nature. The ultimate question is whether or not we acted upon that urge. While teshuva is important and essential, especially in preparation for the High Holidays, it is not necessary to seek atonement because of our feelings or fantasies. This is simply part of our nature.

Temple Beth-El -- Birmingham, Alabama